Well I don't know about you but I read this book and thought it was absolutely fantastic. For me it was just one of those books you read and then nod to yourself saying "yep, that was fantasy". It was back in Arda or whatever the Tolkien world is called, but because it was way back in the early days it felt like new territory for me as the reader, and it was also nice to focus on one main protag for a change. The grim darkness I thought was pulled off perfectly, and it was really interesting having such a flawed protag to follow.
So yeah, as you can tell I've got nothing but good stuff to say about it, how did you Scribes find the book?