Amanita
Maester
What are your feelings about torture scenes in fantasy books? They're quite common, that much I know but different works deal with them in very different ways.
Do you like if they're more or less explicit, do you prefer a fade to black or some kind of "magical means of torture".
Most explicit torture scenes I've stumbled over have been in fanfiction and most of the time, I didn't really see how they added to the plot. As weird as it may sound, detailed descriptions of bleeding wounds, breaking bones and sexual violence aren't very interesting to me.
I care more about the aftermath of it all, and found in other works that this is more powerful if the reader only finds out a few bits of what's happend and the rest is left to their imagination.
In my work, two such cases are turning up and they have the additional problem that both the torturerer and the prisoner are view-point characters.
In one situation an agent of one country's secret service is captured by the enemy country's secret police which normally tends to resort to torture and interrogated by an officer who is actually after the same threat the agent from the other country is working against.
In the second case one character doesn't really intend to torture his prisoner but "only" wants to keep her from getting enough oxygen to use some of it for magical purposes. For her, the difference isn't obvious however.
How would you go on about this? And if you did describe the scenes would you do it from the point of view of the victim of the one of the perpetrator?
Do you like if they're more or less explicit, do you prefer a fade to black or some kind of "magical means of torture".
Most explicit torture scenes I've stumbled over have been in fanfiction and most of the time, I didn't really see how they added to the plot. As weird as it may sound, detailed descriptions of bleeding wounds, breaking bones and sexual violence aren't very interesting to me.
I care more about the aftermath of it all, and found in other works that this is more powerful if the reader only finds out a few bits of what's happend and the rest is left to their imagination.
In my work, two such cases are turning up and they have the additional problem that both the torturerer and the prisoner are view-point characters.
In one situation an agent of one country's secret service is captured by the enemy country's secret police which normally tends to resort to torture and interrogated by an officer who is actually after the same threat the agent from the other country is working against.
In the second case one character doesn't really intend to torture his prisoner but "only" wants to keep her from getting enough oxygen to use some of it for magical purposes. For her, the difference isn't obvious however.
How would you go on about this? And if you did describe the scenes would you do it from the point of view of the victim of the one of the perpetrator?