1. Welcome to the Fantasy Writing Forums. Register Now to join us.

The Hobbit and Lord of the Rings

Discussion in 'Film & Television' started by Kennith E Perry, Sep 18, 2020.

  1. Kennith E Perry

    Kennith E Perry Scribe

    I just spent this week watching all 6 films for the first time in years. I saw scenes I didn't remember. I forgot how much I loved these movies. I hope the new series coming to Prime will be good. I will need to watch these again sooner and not wait 5 or 6 years to watch them again.
  2. S J Lee

    S J Lee Sage

    Sorry dude, though I was glad to see fantasy was mainstream, and love the books, and I saw the first movie 3 times in the cinema, the second and third LOTR movies were good in places, but a bit crap in places. Too much video-game-cut-scene with ridiculous huge graphics crammed in everywhere, all the subtlety of the books gone. Never watched the hobbit movies, the silly mass-CGI battle scenes I saw on Youtube made no sense. Just one man's opinion... let's get a poll!
    Maunus likes this.
  3. Kennith E Perry

    Kennith E Perry Scribe

    I know some people didn't like them, that's fine, everyone has an opinion. I don't like it when some pompous critic thinks that their opinion is right and if any person liked it, they are just stupid. It's like when someone claims they hated Phantom Menace but watch it with the other Star Wars movies.
  4. CupofJoe

    CupofJoe Myth Weaver

    I would loved to have seen Guillermo Del Toro's version of the Hobbit. It was supposed to be far more of a Fairy Tale and only two films... I like the way he makes things look, realy and mythic at the same time.
    Maunus and Nighty_Knight like this.
  5. The Ralph Bakshi animated version is still the best - too bad they only were able to make the first half!
  6. Nighty_Knight

    Nighty_Knight Minstrel

    Lord of the Rings was fantastic. They did mess up a few parts and went a bit over the top for some parts of the battle scenes, especially Legolas. And how the Battle of Pelennor Fields ending change wasn’t good and a bit of a Dues ex Machina.
    The Hobbit movies had potential but had way too much added to them. Someone should do a fan cut and limit it to one 3 hour movie with only stuff from the books really included.
    Hir i-Chorvath likes this.

Share This Page