Here here! Some that express a wide range of emotions from not feeling well/grossed out, to banging head on wall/what was this person thinking.
Here's a few possibilities, in order of how much I like them. These were the best fantasy ones I could find quickly on this one site, but there's other sites too. I think you might be able to use more than one group. In fact there's surprisingly little overlap between all four of these groups.
Dragon Emoticons | 18.435 MSN Smileys
Sketched Morte Emoticons | 18.435 MSN Smileys
Wizards Multicoloured Emoticons | 18.435 MSN Smileys
Lord Of The Rings Emoticons | 18.435 MSN Smileys
Last edited: