Johnny Cosmo
Inkling
Oops, accidentally used words instead of characters, but I still think the point remains. At least, I wouldn't make the character limit larger.
I do think story trading is a good idea. Perhaps users could have a showcase within their profile, where they upload their work in whole. Then use the showcase forums for specific critique.
Well, I was thinking that the writer posts scenes that really showcase what aspect of writing they want work on. That doesn't mean that responses that cover other areas still won't be helpful. There wouldn't have to be any strict rules about exactly what sort of critique is given, just a line in the original post about what the user is trying to address.
I do think story trading is a good idea. Perhaps users could have a showcase within their profile, where they upload their work in whole. Then use the showcase forums for specific critique.
I know some people look for certain things they might be working on in their writing, but if people are picky about the critique they get, then that limits the people who will even bother.
Well, I was thinking that the writer posts scenes that really showcase what aspect of writing they want work on. That doesn't mean that responses that cover other areas still won't be helpful. There wouldn't have to be any strict rules about exactly what sort of critique is given, just a line in the original post about what the user is trying to address.