• Welcome to the Fantasy Writing Forums. Register Now to join us!

Have you ever had a villain be unexpectedly fun to write?

Normally I don't have 'fun' writing villains because well, they're bad guys, I design them in ways that well, the reader and characters should hate them. Which, awkwardly makes it annoying to write them sometimes. I would really rather not write 'vile' characters if I could, but most stories need some kind of antagonist.

Unexpectedly is the key word here. I had foreshadowed this character a couple chapters ahead in sinbad, so the reader will have an 'idea' of what to expect. But she surprised even me. She's 'sexy' and she knows it, hams it up even (with a smarmy grin) and she speaks in third person (Using her name to refer to herself) and she's powerful enough that even my stronger protagonists struggle against her. The protagonists will eventually defeat her (Maybe even convince her to change her ways, since she's mostly in it for personal 'amusement' as she calls it)

I wasn't planning on her being the well 'comically sexy' type of villain, well, she has the body for it. I intended for her to be a more 'serious' villain. But she revealed herself that way and it was pretty fun to write her as a result. Shame I lost the chapter I introduced her in (and the chapter before that) due to losing a memory card. But still.
 
Villains and "badasses" are almost invariably fun to write.
Villains are indeed 'fun'
Though I don't like them as characters (Usually due to being ya know evil) however I understand fantasy adventures need villains lol

Some types of villains make me uncomfy to write, but I think that's a good sign that the reader may hate their guts too. I usually avoid the kinds of villains that do despicable things. But they do do villainous stuff, if that makes sense?

If most of my protagonists want to 'put them down' I'm pretty sure I do to, and hopefully the readers will enjoy them in that way.

And when the time comes (if it comes, Dante may do a heel Turn to the baddies at some point, just the vibes I'm getting from her) they are going to be metaphorically singing frank Senatras 'I did it my way' lol

I have a feeling Dante will potentially be an enjoyable villain for the reader. She's smart enough to switch sides if push comes to shove, though convincing her to do so won't be easy. She's very, let's say set in her ways. I've been writing her as one of those 'sexy' villains, but she knows when to reign it in and focus. She knows how to read the room too and take things seriously.
 
I have. Though it was more like a protagonist who was a downright asshole. Great fun to write. Part of it is that it's fairly easy to inject a lot of character into someone being terrible. The other is that it's a way of putting all those ideas floating around in your head down on paper. Like when you see someone behave terrible and you think that it would be amazing if someone just gave them a good beating. But you can't because that's not how real life works. Well, now you can.

I really should write more bad guys. They're the best.
 
I have. Though it was more like a protagonist who was a downright asshole. Great fun to write. Part of it is that it's fairly easy to inject a lot of character into someone being terrible. The other is that it's a way of putting all those ideas floating around in your head down on paper. Like when you see someone behave terrible and you think that it would be amazing if someone just gave them a good beating. But you can't because that's not how real life works. Well, now you can.

I really should write more bad guys. They're the best.
I have a protagonist who's like that.

By all means, she's quite a bit of a smart ass. She's sassy as F* too, talks about doing a "D 20" whenever the group is going to do something stupid. (This is a universe where the characters are aware of those tropes in fiction) BUT at her core, she's a good/hard working person. She's just fed up with not getting her paid due for all her adventuring.

She gets to BE Sassy /smart ass-y because she has the skill to back it up. Imagine if Legolas was kinda throwing zingers every now and then. (I mean he kinda does but not in the way I mean, if that makes sense) She's like that. At one point she's shown taking the moment seriously like the rest of the group is. The group and even the villain they're confronting are shocked. She responds with 'what, even *I* can't be spewing zingers 24/7 ya know!' which lightens the tension of the room a bit.
 
More often than not, people believe that they are justified in their actions, no matter the moral or ethical components. Understanding this, I think, is the key to writing nuanced, believable villains.
Yep, there's a guy in a show I'm a fan of, absolute villain (But he's 'small fry' compared to the big villains of the show) but he is entertaining to watch, and watch get punched. He's so confident in what he's doing that he doesn't stop to think it might backfire (Either with or without the protagonists interfering) and I like that in a bad guy. He might be a 'class clown' in a 'circus' of eccentric villains, but dangit if he isn't a fun villain to watch.

You might be thinking I'm talking about The Joker from Batman. But nah, He's Roman Torchwick from RWBY. Throughout his appearance, Roman is painted as 'just a guy' (Sometimes literally, in comparison to the other villains) trying to make it big in the villain scene. I think that's what makes him entertaining.
 

pmmg

Myth Weaver
I don't know about unexpected. I enjoy all of my characters. I have two villains that were killed off in their first draft only to decide I'd rather have them continue in the next book, so I rewrote it that they survived for another day.

Perhaps the villain I enjoy the most, is Rumsha the Bone Reader, mostly because he lacks the brute strength to assure his rise and has to be more cunning than all the rest. He is often unexpectantly dangerous, and very Evil in his thoughts and deeds. But...He is a secondary or tertiary character.

Generally, I enjoy my heroes more. I don't get tired of writing the lead.


(Thinking some more, I have another character I killed off, that I would like to show has somehow survived, but...I feel it would hurt the story if he did, so killed off he remains.)
 

A. E. Lowan

Forum Mom
Leadership
I love our antagonists. We have Protagonists, Antagonists, and Monkeys in the Middle. People do terrible things for all the right reasons. And perfectly normal people will do evil things not out of a desire to harm, but from a desire to not get involved. There are no excuses, but there are so many reasons.

At the moment, I'm having a great deal of fun with this lovely nightmare. This is Tatjana, one of a mother-son pair of pattern killers. She is deeply wounded and still in the same place that made her this way.

"Gun was one thing. When I found out the second time that it was a girl, I cried for a week. The world and my family would eat her alive, and there was nothing I could do to protect her. And then Vilhelm took her away from me. He didn't let me hold her. He didn't even let me name her. Next time I saw her, it was her 6th birthday. She didn't even know me from pictures. I was a stranger trying in vain to smile at her while offering her a gift without any meaning for either of us."

Tatjana is a creature of fire and rage, and she has very deep feels about how she got that way. And the fire in her blood knows jsut the best way to get vengeance. Best served cold, her ass. When she's done, she burn hot enough to reduce bricks to gritty dust, and no one will ever get to hurt her, again.

1b82e6c307a5c3e9ec8f51e7c925aabe.jpg
 
Mesagonists? Meso-agonists? Mesotists? Middleotists?

I'm going with mesagonists because it's the weirdest one.

Also, did you just give us a teaser for book nr 4? :love:
I think she means villains / heroes who play both sides for their own gain, but I'm not sure what to call those either.

Dante will be one of those, she only does what she needs to in order to meet her objectives (Whatever's amusing her at the time) she's playing the long game and has been considering changing sides for the longest time, but she's hung up on if people would actually see her as a 'hero' if she did. The protagonists (especially the one she 'toyed with' ) try to convince her and that's what's going to push her to do the heel turn.

As I said, she's highly intelligent, she's not one of those 'evil for the sake of evil' villains (Which have their place, but boy am I sick of them in RPGs) so if any baddie in my story is going to do a heel turn, likely her.
 

Mad Swede

Auror
I enjoy writing all characters, protagonists and antagonists alike. There's something about watching them develop through the story which gives me a great deal of pleasure.

As an author I detest terms like "villain" and "bad guy" when discussing writing, because in my view that risks resulting in lazy and cliched stories and critiques. Given that so much of what I write is based on personal experience I much prefer nuanced characters with their own reasons for their actions. Such characters can be very sympathetic whilst at the same time being very antagostic to (some) other characters and for me this makes for a more interesting set of story and character arcs. At the end of the day it's all about characterisation.
 

A. E. Lowan

Forum Mom
Leadership
Mesagonists? Meso-agonists? Mesotists? Middleotists?

I'm going with mesagonists because it's the weirdest one.

Also, did you just give us a teaser for book nr 4? :love:
Better. It's a piece among a great many. I'm getting the pieces in my head, rapid fire. We've just about filled my brain with enough material to see the story taking shape. This is one of my favorite phases of production.

Also, should anyone want a bigger tease...
5977c175119a4564fa900ec4600cb4a5.jpg
 

A. E. Lowan

Forum Mom
Leadership
I think she means villains / heroes who play both sides for their own gain, but I'm not sure what to call those either.

Dante will be one of those, she only does what she needs to in order to meet her objectives (Whatever's amusing her at the time) she's playing the long game and has been considering changing sides for the longest time, but she's hung up on if people would actually see her as a 'hero' if she did. The protagonists (especially the one she 'toyed with' ) try to convince her and that's what's going to push her to do the heel turn.

As I said, she's highly intelligent, she's not one of those 'evil for the sake of evil' villains (Which have their place, but boy am I sick of them in RPGs) so if any baddie in my story is going to do a heel turn, likely her.
Got to say, I love gender bending Dante's name. It delights me.
 
Got to say, I love gender bending Dante's name. It delights me.
I was writing her in Chapter 5 (which was sadly lost when my SD card Broke, chapter 4 too) and she decided that was her name, and that she spoke in third person lol Nothing fancy going on to begin with other than using a male name for a woman though. She was just like 'hey so I like Dante as a name it suits me' and I rolled with it lol

You might like Dante as a character, she's an RPG villain (Think Final Fantasy etc ) through and through but she knows when to reign it in and take things serious. She's one of the few 'villains' in my story that are like 'wait hold the phone, I'm on the wrong team' and she doesn't make this decision lightly. It takes some convincing but the seeds of curiosity/doubt are planted in her early. The other proper villain that joins them does so on a survivalist mindset, but they also warm up to the group. They have their own reasons for doubting being a bad guy. but they don't take much convincing.
 

KeeGaN

Sage
I like the villain that was once the best friend. A bit like X the anime. (Or maybe that is an evil twin.) The first reaction I get to writing a villain, is redeemable characteristics. Sometimes they committed a sin, or performed a great deed, but I lack the moral apathy to produce something like a Dark Lord. (It has been done before, get me wrong.)

I think what I realise from books I read, is the constant pushing of the bar, of what is good and evil. Some characters have no redeemable qualities, and it is what draws you in and makes you commit, there is no two ways about it. (I do feel like villains are in a special club.)
 
I like the villain that was once the best friend. A bit like X the anime. (Or maybe that is an evil twin.) The first reaction I get to writing a villain, is redeemable characteristics. Sometimes they committed a sin, or performed a great deed, but I lack the moral apathy to produce something like a Dark Lord. (It has been done before, get me wrong.)
Those villains can be good but like all things done in writing, I'm not going to give one cobbled together for zero reason a pass. If you're going to do that with a character it kinda needs a purpose for the betrayal. This trope happened in MHS 3 and there was no hints at it whatsoever. I kinda like the plot point more if that person was 'always' evil rather than oh, suddenly something traumatic happened that turned them to the dark side.

A Dark Lord is a great excuse to go as cartoonish as possible with your villain, but there's a time and place for those types of villains too. Not every fantasy story needs one. I haven't yet attempted a dark lord (At least in that sense) because I find them a little too cartoonish in most stories. There's a reason video games don't rely on them as much anymore.
I think what I realise from books I read, is the constant pushing of the bar, of what is good and evil. Some characters have no redeemable qualities, and it is what draws you in and makes you commit, there is no two ways about it. (I do feel like villains are in a special club.)
There is a club for villains.
It's called Ihopp (International house of Problematic People)
 

MADarkforge

New Member
Normally I don't have 'fun' writing villains because well, they're bad guys, I design them in ways that well, the reader and characters should hate them. Which, awkwardly makes it annoying to write them sometimes. I would really rather not write 'vile' characters if I could, but most stories need some kind of antagonist.

Unexpectedly is the key word here. I had foreshadowed this character a couple chapters ahead in sinbad, so the reader will have an 'idea' of what to expect. But she surprised even me. She's 'sexy' and she knows it, hams it up even (with a smarmy grin) and she speaks in third person (Using her name to refer to herself) and she's powerful enough that even my stronger protagonists struggle against her. The protagonists will eventually defeat her (Maybe even convince her to change her ways, since she's mostly in it for personal 'amusement' as she calls it)

I wasn't planning on her being the well 'comically sexy' type of villain, well, she has the body for it. I intended for her to be a more 'serious' villain. But she revealed herself that way and it was pretty fun to write her as a result. Shame I lost the chapter I introduced her in (and the chapter before that) due to losing a memory card. But still.
I think the thing about villains is that, no matter what kind of villain they are or which aspect of them you choose to magnify, they allow you to tap into a side of yourself that doesn’t get to show in the real world. Whether it’s a part of you that already exists or a part of you that longs to possess some quality you’ve given the villain, it’s a metaphysical journey your conscious mind doesn’t normally get to take.
 
I think the thing about villains is that, no matter what kind of villain they are or which aspect of them you choose to magnify, they allow you to tap into a side of yourself that doesn’t get to show in the real world. Whether it’s a part of you that already exists or a part of you that longs to possess some quality you’ve given the villain, it’s a metaphysical journey your conscious mind doesn’t normally get to take.
For villains I like to give them a reason to be evil. 'just born evil' never sat right with me as an excuse for a villain. It CAN work, if given the right context. But I need something more justified than that. There are the ones who just like to start fires, but I'm not sure those count as 'evil' those are just more bundles of chaos that grew into the wrong direction.

Heck, the main villain in my story now isn't even properly evil, she's more of a natural disaster personified. (Think like the smog from ferngully )

With Dante, she's a fire starter for sure, she loves to cause chaos, but, she doesn't particularly mind which 'side' she causes said chaos. (She's very much one of those 'protagonist of her own story' types ) She's been debating for the last 10 or so years if 'evil' is really all it's cracked up to be. (though she does have fun doing her sinister laugh that she totally doesn't practice for hours in front of a mirror...) She was ignorant of her reputation for a long time, and the protagonists flip a switch in her brain (perhaps unintentionally) and she goes 'wait, THAT is why I have such a horrid reputation? Why didn't you say so 300 years ago!' she even admits that she's fully aware that her reputation won't change right away. But she sees it as a challenge.
 

pmmg

Myth Weaver
I think the thing about villains is that, no matter what kind of villain they are or which aspect of them you choose to magnify, they allow you to tap into a side of yourself that doesn’t get to show in the real world. Whether it’s a part of you that already exists or a part of you that longs to possess some quality you’ve given the villain, it’s a metaphysical journey your conscious mind doesn’t normally get to take.

Wouldn't this be true for the Hero as well? All of our characters carry some aspect of ourselves.
 
Top