Queshire
Istar
Have you ever taken a logic class? A False Dichotomy is a logical fallacy implying that there's only two options when that is not the case. I did not change the hypothetical in any way, I took the information you presented and showed that those are by far not the only two options.
Further your hypothetical situation in no way crystalizes the point you were trying to make, it was a weak argument at best.
True, the answer to a hypothetical situation doesn't reflect what would happen in a similar real life situation, there are simply too many variables to take into account, but if there's no point in the hypothetical, then why'd you bring it up in the first place?
It is testable, I tested it in my last post
Look, I'll do it again;
If good is objective, then everybody's concept of good would be the same. Are they the same? No, no they are not. True, they are similar, not same, but similar, but that is explained as a result of evolution, instinct, and culture. Therefore good is not objective.
Further your hypothetical situation in no way crystalizes the point you were trying to make, it was a weak argument at best.
True, the answer to a hypothetical situation doesn't reflect what would happen in a similar real life situation, there are simply too many variables to take into account, but if there's no point in the hypothetical, then why'd you bring it up in the first place?
It is testable, I tested it in my last post
Look, I'll do it again;
If good is objective, then everybody's concept of good would be the same. Are they the same? No, no they are not. True, they are similar, not same, but similar, but that is explained as a result of evolution, instinct, and culture. Therefore good is not objective.