• Welcome to the Fantasy Writing Forums. Register Now to join us!

"The tower stood where stone met timber, where rich met poor—a bridge..."

medieval_page

New Member
Please give this a quick read and provide some constructive criticism, this is my first medieval fantasy and I'm willing to learn. Thank you so much!!!

This is the first short chapter of a book idea I have.


Chapter One.
The tower creaked like an old lung, breathing against the gray breath of morning. Each gust made the timbers groan and whisper, the sound swallowed by the vast emptiness of the high moors beyond the castle walls.

Timn pressed his hand to the rung above him and climbed, feeling the wet cold of dew seep through his wool sleeves. His breath came sharp and white in the air. Below, the kingdom lay drowned in fog—its tiled roofs and crooked chimneys barely visible, its castle towers rising like black teeth above a mouth of mist. The paupers’ huts of the lower quarter were dim, scattered coals from some dying fire of men.

He climbed higher, the old rope ladder sighing under his weight. He had done this every morning since his twelfth birthday, when the Keeper of the Light had first placed the flint striker in his trembling hands and said, “This flame binds the realm, boy. Guard it as you would your heart.”

The tower stood where stone met timber, where rich met poor—a bridge between the gilded halls of the castle and the smoke-stained alleys of the commonfolk. It had been raised in the first days of the King’s peace, when men still believed that light could hold back darkness, that a single flame might make brothers of lords and herdsmen.

When the bowl torch burned, its light could be seen for leagues in every direction. Shepherds in the northern highlands would lift their heads to it, and fishermen at sea would murmur blessings under their breath. To the croppers of the eastern plain and the lumberers of the southern wood, that light was the King’s promise—of order, safety, mercy.

But promises, Timn had learned, dim more easily than flame.

He was fourteen now. Lean, wiry, his palms rough from rope and rung. The morning chill bit into him as he climbed, but he welcomed the sting; it meant he was alive, and the world still turned. Halfway up, he paused to rest his legs and turned eastward. The horizon was a sheet of pale steel, the kind that holds its breath before dawn.

Then he heard it.

Not the usual groan of chains or the mutter of sentries changing watch. This sound was softer. More deliberate. The steady, rhythmic pulse of hooves striking wet cobblestone.

He froze, pressing himself against the tower’s frame. His eyes found the castle courtyard far below—movement there, just visible through the thinning mist. Shapes, half a dozen or more, gliding like wraiths between the stables and the keep. They wore no heraldry, no torches. Cloaks of green and brown, mottled to blend with stone and fog.

Something in their gait chilled him. They moved like men used to killing.

Timn narrowed his eyes, straining to see. The shapes halted near the keep’s inner doors. There—a brief flash of steel, then a cry strangled before it could rise. A guard fell. The others slipped through the entryway, swallowed by the shadows of the King’s hall.

Moments later, they reemerged.

This time they were not alone. Between them struggled a man in white nightclothes, his bare feet dragging, his crown of gray hair catching what little light there was.

The King.

Timn’s heart stuttered in his chest. He gripped the rung so hard his knuckles bled white.

The men bound the monarch’s hands, flung him across a waiting horse, and spurred toward the north gate. All of it wordless, efficient, unseen but for the boy on the tower. The fog swallowed them whole.

He turned upward. The great bowl torch loomed above him—cold, unlit, the kingdom’s symbol of peace. His hand went to the flint at his belt. One strike, one spark, and the fire would blaze for all to see. The light is lit. The King is safe. That was the law.

But the King was not safe.

And only Timn knew.

The wind rose, moaning through the slats, whipping his hair into his eyes. His fingers hovered between truth and duty, between silence and signal. If he lit the flame, the lie would spread across the realm, comforting thousands. If he didn’t, panic would rise with the dawn—and the blame would fall squarely on him.

Then came another sound.

This one not from the castle, but from below. Inside the tower.

Wood creaked. Boots scraped against rungs. Someone was climbing. Fast. Silent.

Timn’s pulse thundered in his ears. He peered downward and saw only darkness between the beams, the faint glimmer of movement—a shape ascending, wrapped in shadow. Not one of the watchmen. Too quiet. Too quick.

“Who’s there?” Timn called, voice cracking against the wind.

No answer. Only the soft rasp of leather on wood.

He reached for the flint, gripping it like a dagger. The figure halted a few feet beneath him. Then a voice came—low, rough, the tone of someone who had seen too much of war.

“You saw them,” the man said. Not a question.

Timn hesitated. “Who are you?”

The climber moved closer until his hooded face came into view—sharp features, a scar dragging down one cheek, and beneath his cloak, a glint of darkened metal. A guard’s badge, blackened by flame.

“They can’t know,” the man said quietly. “Not yet.”

Before Timn could speak, the stranger climbed past him, nimble as a wolf, and hauled himself up to the torch’s rim. From his satchel, he poured a thick, tar-black oil into the bowl, the smell acrid and wrong.

He struck the flint himself.

Fire leapt skyward with a roar that shook the tower. The light blazed against the gray dawn, brighter than the sun, a pillar of gold piercing the mist.

The man turned, eyes hollow in the firelight. “You’ll tell them you lit it,” he said. “And if you value the King’s life—say nothing else.”

He dropped the flint into the flame and descended the other side without another word, vanishing into the fog as quickly as he’d come.

Timn stood frozen, his face lit orange and gold, the wind thrashing his cloak. Below, the castle walls caught the light and gleamed. Across the valley, farmers and fishers, woodsmen and shepherds—all lifted their heads toward the tower and smiled.

The Light was burning.
The King was safe.
And the first lie of the new age began to glow.
 
Last edited:

AlexS

Scribe
I like it, just a few comments:

1. Would be better if the King was named (eg. Haylenn the II or whatever), would make the reader better connect to his fate than just "the King". Also, the King could look up for a moment, and it seems to Timn their eyes met - or did they?

2. I don't understand the logic here: "If he didn’t, panic would rise with the dawn—and the blame would fall squarely on him."
Why would he be blamed? The fire signifies the King is safe, so if the King's not safe, and Timn didn't light the fire, he'd be doing his job. Unless I'm missing something.

3. During this process: "The men bound the monarch’s hands, flung him across a waiting horse, and spurred toward the north gate. All of it wordless, efficient, unseen but for the boy on the tower. The fog swallowed them whole."
Consider adding a beat of Timn's internal conflict. Should he do something? Rush down? Scream? Anything? He may not be able to do anything, but the fact he's not even considering it, makes him too passive here.
 

A. E. Lowan

Forum Mom
Leadership
Page, just a couple of bits to help you out and welcome you to Scribes. First, you'll get a better response when you've made a few more posts and shown how you interact with the community and also let us get more familiar with you and your interests and needs. That's just good, all around advice for any forum.

When you've responded to more threads, you'll have the option of posting in the Critique Requests sub-forum. That's where most of us go to have our individual work looked at. My question at just this moment, is why did he drop the flint? Let me introduce myself. I'm Lowan, the Evil Queen of Why. Also Cannibal Queen. I admit it's been a while since I was without matches, but if I recall correctly, dropping a flint like that is akin to dropping your lighter. Now you have no 'easy' fire at hand.

I actully met my team's alpha reader like this. His first story, and I had to explain to a teenage boy that it wasn't a good plan to start a fire big enough to cook over in what was basically a pup tent. Also some about archery.

Good luck and have fun!
 

Incanus

Auror
I’ll keep this a tad short, not knowing if this poster will return or not.

First of all, I second AE Lowan’s post—stick around, join a conversation, use the critique request section of the site—that’s the way things work best.

In general, this is pretty good. I like that there is a sense of ‘place’ in this piece, something lacking in a lot of amateur fiction.

Like AlexS, I was confused about why Timn would be blamed if he didn’t light the fire/beacon. Could this be some misapprehension by the character, like he is wrong on this point?

The biggest problem here (in my view) is that the King is abducted far too easily. There is only one guard between the King and the whole rest of the world? Why was the courtyard not defended? The security seems woefully inadequate. Also, how come there are no other witnesses? Royal family member? Servants? Other officials? Kings are rarely alone, even in their bedchambers.

Wouldn’t this work a little better if the abductors employed some kind of magic to make this more plausible? Stealth magic, or memory-erasing magic for the witnesses. Something.

I have further observations, but we’ll leave it at that for now.

Anyway, good luck with this—a promising start.
 

SamazonE

Troubadour
When the bowl torch burned, its light could be seen for leagues in every direction. Shepherds in the northern highlands would lift their heads to it, and fishermen at sea would murmur blessings under their breath.
It has a nice ring to it. Who is the King? I’d like to know more.
But promises, Timn had learned, dim more easily than flame.
I was wondering about this because the action begins here. There are a few scuffles that I had to over read.
Not the usual groan of chains or the mutter of sentries changing watch. This sound was softer. More deliberate. The steady, rhythmic pulse of hooves striking wet cobblestone.
Maybe if you made the violence prolonged it would translate, but there is the incessant gap of cognition, that has me reeling.
All of it wordless, efficient, unseen but for the boy on the tower.
I would change it to inefficient, so we are there alongside the boy.
 

minta

Troubadour
Wow, this is really strong for a first chapter. Overall, the chapter grips the reader, builds suspense, and sets up the world beautifully. It’s the kind of opening that makes me want to read the next chapter immediately. ;)
 

Remedian

Dreamer
Really great first chapter. It hooked me early on. Iam not an expert in this but ill tell you how felt reading it so you can get feedback. Um the way they abducted the king was fast. it feels like theyre only separated by a wooden fence which the rider just hopped through went inside pushed a guard and took the king. But it was told on the perspective of the boy which was high up on the tower so its kind of justified? But idk i feel like there should be a long pause when they went inside to increase the tension i feel like. But its mostly nitpicking. Anyway its really great. Id like to read the next chapter.
 

pmmg

Myth Weaver
For me, I felt overwhelmed with detail. Almost every sentence has extra description stuffed into them, which was wearing me out. I think it could be toned down a bit, and save the reader a bit of work. Overall, it is very detailed, and its pretty clear what is meant in each sentence of the story. Some of it is pretty nice, and drawing attention in a clever way. I just think its a bit thick with it.

I was not confused on why he would be blamed. But I also think the King could have a name.
 
Top