Page 2 of 2 FirstFirst 12
Results 11 to 18 of 18

Thread: Is there a such thing as "HISTORICAL FANTASY" if so, are there rules?

  1. #11
    Junior Member kikyo's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2017
    Location
    TN
    Posts
    16
    Portfolio Entries
    3
    Reputation
    25
    Quote Originally Posted by elemtilas View Post
    Guess it depends on "how much history" and "how much fantasy" are in the mix. Is it just Egypt-like (think Djelibeybe) or is it actual Egypt with hordes of mummy warriors and so forth. Oh, wait, that's been done! So, yeah. Historical fantasy is a thing, so no worries!

    Even Harry Potter has "some historical facts", so I don't see an issue with setting a fantasy story in a real country a long time ago.
    It is actually in Egypt and I use some of the rivers, canals, and cities that existed back then. Along with descriptions of how the locations, palaces, etc. looked along with basic things that they actually used (linen clothing, cosmetic things such as perfumes and paste for bathing, etc)
    I have been doing a ton of research to stick to how things actually were back then!


    xoxo,
    KIKYO

  2. #12
    Junior Member kikyo's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2017
    Location
    TN
    Posts
    16
    Portfolio Entries
    3
    Reputation
    25
    Quote Originally Posted by Steerpike View Post
    Read Guy Gavriel Kay's "historical fantasies." The Lions of Al-Rassan is a good place to start. It is based on true historical events, but he renames the countries and people, placing them in a fantasy world that is essentially a loose analog of our own world.
    Wow renaming the countries and people is brilliant. That sounds like something I could really have fun doing in the future. Thanks for the feedback and reference!


    xoxo,
    KIKYO

  3. #13
    Moderator T.Allen.Smith's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2012
    Location
    Western USA
    Posts
    3,916
    Reputation
    9565
    The currently most popular fantasy series Game of Thrones is based on the historical War of the Roses, and it's barely recognizable in that regard.

    So, yes. You can mix as much, or as little actual factual history as you please.
    "What lasts in the reader's mind is not the phrase but the effect the phrase created: laughter, tears, pain, joy. If the phrase is not affecting the reader, what's it doing there? Make it do its job or cut it without mercy or remorse."
    - ISAAC ASIMOV

  4. #14
    Senior Member FifthView's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2015
    Location
    USA
    Posts
    1,687
    Reputation
    5424
    Yeah, historical fantasy has been done lots of times.

    Mary Robinette Kowal writes in that genre.

    Here's one Writing Excuses podcast in which she and others discuss the subgenre: Writing Excuses 7.7: Historical Fantasy | Writing Excuses

    Just in case, here's an earlier podcast in which they discuss alternate history: Writing Excuses 5.21: Alternate History | Writing Excuses

    I think that this is the difference:

    With alternate history, some major change in a historical event or situation leads to a whole different history for the world after that event. Some common themes: Hitler won WWII, the South won the American Civil War, the Aztecs never fell to Cortés, the dinosaurs were never wiped out by a meteor (or meteor + volcanoes + whatever actually caused their demise.)

    With historical fantasy, you are actually using a real time period but with some magical or fantastical element added. So your idea of using ancient Egypt but adding some fantasy elements would be historical fantasy, I think. This is like writing about Victorian England but adding vampires or werewolves. You could write about Shogunate Japan but add...whatever; maybe, some magic-wielding blacksmith is creating magical katanas, and/or maybe some mythical Japanese creatures/demons are real.

    In historical fantasy, famous persons from history can be used, so your idea of using historical Egyptians is okay. Typically, I think you'd not want historical Egyptians from very different time periods in Egyptian history mixed-and-matched—this also applies to other aspects of the world building—although you could fudge that a little bit. Historical fantasy will fudge like this sometimes. The problem though is that people who actually know about the history might have aneurysms if you do that, hah.
    Last edited by FifthView; 6-20-17 at 11:31 AM.

  5. Thanks Demesnedenoir thanked for this post
  6. #15
    Senior Member Demesnedenoir's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2015
    Location
    Shadowy redoubt of my mind
    Posts
    1,051
    Reputation
    2889
    And the Texas Chainsaw Massacre is "based on a true story". Inspired by might be the better term.

    Quote Originally Posted by T.Allen.Smith View Post
    The currently most popular fantasy series Game of Thrones is based on the historical War of the Roses, and it's barely recognizable in that regard.

    So, yes. You can mix as much, or as little actual factual history as you please.
    Craven Raven, black of feather and black of beak,
    of what today shall we speak?

  7. #16
    Senior Member DragonOfTheAerie's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2016
    Location
    Down the labyrinthine ways of my own mind
    Posts
    2,311
    Reputation
    4295
    Quote Originally Posted by kikyo View Post
    Is it okay to have some historical facts along with some fantasy ideas from your imagination?

    I'm working on a story that takes place in Egypt. Has some characters that existed, such as the first woman pharaoh in history. Also has recorded gods/goddesses and has some characters that didn't actually exist that are basically NPC's.

    Thoughts?
    I've read stuff like this, mostly in the 'fantasy of manners' category. Temeraire comes to mind. And I've heard the term historical fantasy before. I think several books like this have been released in the YA category lately. Yes, it's a thing, and apparently people like and read it.

    But don't ask if it's okay. You can set a story anytime, anyplace, cant you? There are no rules. Write the story that is inside you.
    i am a dragon with torn and broken wings,
    but i am still a dragon

  8. Thanks Sheilawisz thanked for this post
  9. #17
    Moderator Steerpike's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2011
    Location
    R'lyeh
    Posts
    10,254
    Portfolio Entries
    3
    Reputation
    15836
    Guy Gavriel Kay probably does historical fantasy best. Read The Lions of Al-Rassan, for example. He writes a lot in this subgenre.
    All cat stories start with this statement: "My mother, who was the first cat, told me this...”

  10. #18
    Senior Member elemtilas's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2017
    Posts
    116
    Portfolio Entries
    2
    Reputation
    305
    Quote Originally Posted by kikyo View Post
    It is actually in Egypt and I use some of the rivers, canals, and cities that existed back then. Along with descriptions of how the locations, palaces, etc. looked along with basic things that they actually used (linen clothing, cosmetic things such as perfumes and paste for bathing, etc)
    I have been doing a ton of research to stick to how things actually were back then! ...

    Wow renaming the countries and people is brilliant. That sounds like something I could really have fun doing in the future. Thanks for the feedback and reference!
    Ya. I don't see any issue at all with setting a fantasy ěn Egypt per se. I mean, if we take the Arthurian matter or the Ulster Cycle and turn them into works of fantasy, they're still set in Britain & Ireland. They're just fantasy stories set in an otherwise historical location.

    And sure, rename people and countries! Cloud or reveal as much as you'd like of the original source.

Page 2 of 2 FirstFirst 12

Similar Threads

  1. "But it doesn't happen on Earth!" or "But it's a fantasy!"
    By Heliotrope in forum Writing Questions
    Replies: 64
    Last Post: 9-8-16, 3:47 PM
  2. Elmore Leonard's 10 "Rules" of Writing
    By Steerpike in forum Writing Questions
    Replies: 44
    Last Post: 1-11-14, 12:53 AM
  3. "House of Leaves" and the rules of writing
    By Steerpike in forum Writing Questions
    Replies: 7
    Last Post: 1-26-12, 12:27 PM
  4. Lists and References ("the Rules": the other part)
    By Ravana in forum Machiavel: Ambition
    Replies: 13
    Last Post: 1-2-12, 2:55 AM
  5. Care and Feeding of your Barony (aka "the Rules")
    By Ravana in forum Machiavel: Ambition
    Replies: 19
    Last Post: 1-2-12, 12:02 AM

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  

Is there a such thing as "HISTORICAL FANTASY" if so, are there rules?   Is there a such thing as "HISTORICAL FANTASY" if so, are there rules?   Is there a such thing as "HISTORICAL FANTASY" if so, are there rules?