• Welcome to the Fantasy Writing Forums. Register Now to join us!

Need help with an initiative during a siege

Gurkhal

Auror
I'm working on a short story but I got stuck.

The story is about the siege of a city during, technologically, Classical Antiquity by a not!Roman army.What I am asking for is for initiative for the MC to engage in which allows the defenders to hold onto the city until a relief army can force a withdraw of the besiegers.

I am ready to make changes to the story to facilitate this initiative by the MC so if it would go against some stuff written below it shouldn't a problem. I think I can write my way through most problems that might come up.

Some parts of the story and the context that MC operates in

The defenders constitute a hoplite-based citizen army and the besiegers are a manipular legion army, with some allies thrown in to bulk out the numbers. There are maybe 8k defenders (of whom perhaps 1k-2k are hoplites, at most, the rest being light infantry or now dismounted cavalry) and 25k besiegers. 1k of the defenders are under the command of the MC and are outsiders sent to reinforce the defense of the city.

Around 5th-4th century BC level of technology

Its and inland city

The city is build on a cliff, or acropolis, with cliff sides on all sides but the south where the gate is positioned in the wall

Through the use of siege engines the attackers have breached the walls in several places on the southern side

The defenders will need to hold out for some ten days before the relief arrives

The way of war used by the not!Romans are methodical, careful, well planned and steady but also predictable and not very innovative

A surprise attack to burn the siege engines have been considered but discarded as the besiegers are well organized and have their positions well placed and planned for such eventualities

The besiegers are planning to take the city by storm before the relief army can arrive. The plan so far is to first create breaches in the wall, then wear down the defenders with the allied troops and the Hastati before the Principes deliver one, or more, blows to break the defenses. The Triarii will probably sit this one out.

Two initiatives taken by other characters are; tear down buildings in the city to try and fill in breaches by labor units during the night and that a cavalry vanguard from the relief army arrives early to spook the besiegers and start causing mischief for them

I'm happy to answer further questions as I really want to get the story moving again
 

pmmg

Myth Weaver
Maybe fill the breaches with stuff to burn and start a fire that makes it impassable till it burns out.

If they have more than one wall, they could do something to cause delays at one wall, while they do real repairs to another.

They could just decisively defend, at the cost a many lives, but still hold the line.

There could be a secret tunnel out of the city, that lets them perform a night raid and set the siege engines on fire.

Maybe the collapse the road into a sewer system, making the breach a depression the enemy cannot enter without becoming trapped and easy picking for spears and arrows.

They could take a heard of bulls, or pigs or such, set them on fire and let them loose into the advancing enemy army.

A movable plank wall that could be wheeled in front of the breach, creating a second short term barrier.

Misdirection. Get bad intel the enemy making them believe an ally is coming sooner, or that the east quarter is ready to fall, when really they aren't, still causing the enemy to act as if it were true and wasting man power and efforts.

A draw bridge that they could smash, making it impassable.
 

KeeGaN

Sage
There could be some insurgents. A wall is difficult to breach, so they have these ballista rams, and means of scaling the wall. There are towers, and ropes, grappling hooks to make it secure. In the process of drilling a wall, some friendlies make it out of the hole, don some regalia, and begin making alterations to the equipment. In this process, a sizeable number of them are crushed by the sawed wood and frayed rope.

A fine way to end a battle has been to send out a champion, but if it is a ten day siege, then it would be about taking the city and its resources. A peninsula would be better than cliffs, because they could escape on ships, maybe waiting for the reinforcements to arrive, leaving the city defenceless and ultimately captured.
 
8k Defenders against 25k attackers doesn't sound too hopeless (going with the default 1-10 defenders advantage). The location sounds relatively easy to defend even with the walls breached. Also, the interesting bits usually aren't people hitting other people with swords. Rather, it's the character stuff surrounding it.

With that in mind, I would look at making the MC involved in all the organizing stuff. You already mentioned filling in the breaches in the walls. Lots of room for conflict there. After all, why are you tearing down my house when my neighbours house is bigger and he's an asshole?

But also, you mention he's an outsider. That means they need to work together with the local garisson. But they might distrust each other, and blame the others for taking the easy jobs. After all, someone needs to defend that wall over the cliff no sane attacker would try to attack, but I'd like it to be me and my troops, since I like being alive... Or maybe some parts of the city want to just surrender (the notRomans could send an envoy to discuss terms).

Then there's the issue of food. Now, 10 days isn't long. But maybe the city didn't stockpile enough food, or something happened to it, creating a precarious situation. Especially with 1000 outsiders.

That is the sort of things I would look at here, the antagonists inside the city. Who opposes the MC and why? And having them be inside the city gives you an actual chance to interact. You can't have 10k people all have the same ideas and feelings.

Also remember, that if you have the 10 day time limit, then the attackers will probably also be aware of this. Which might make them more desparate as time goes on. After all, you don't want to still be fighting when the relief forces arrive.

Sidenote: I think the best siege story I read was 16 ways to defend a walled city. It's a comedy though, which pulls some ideas into the ridiculous. But it does show this dynamic wonderfully.
 

Karlin

Inkling
Some really good suggestions have been posted. You can take them, and make the MC the agent that pushes them forward. Rainstorm? He's a rainmaker, or convinces one to act. Another thought- raiding parties that attack the besiegers food or water supplies, or even divert them.
 

pmmg

Myth Weaver
He leads a wedge attack past the wall, into the enemy line to target and destroy their water supply. Then retreats as soon as it happens.

Oh...see you have that covered.

Maybe they lead a raid, and injure the other sides commander, leaving a loss of leadership.
 
Last edited:

Mad Swede

Auror
OK, writing this as a professional in the field...

Assuming your not!Roman army is has a competent commander then they should have built a circumvallation to prevent a relief army attacking them from the rear. That means the attacking relief army will need to be about twice the size of the not!Roman force to have any chance of success.

However, the not!Roman army isn't really big enough to make a successful quick attack. There are more than enough defenders to hold off an attack simply because the cliffs and the restricted length of the southern wall is going to prevent the not!Romans from outflanking the defenders and because the breaches won't be wide enough to allow the not!Romans to use numerical superiority to overrun the defenders. All your MC really needs to do is boil some oil and get it up on the walls around the breaches, because then they can pour ir on to the attackers. Better still if the MC builds a few small catapults and then uses these to throw barrels of boiling oil onto the attackers lining up to get through the breaches.

Your MC may also want to consider a few small night time raids. These could be used to burn supplies (especially food), damage any water barrels the attackers are using and kill a few of the attackers. The MC could also set a few fires to spook any horses the attackets may have.

The only concern I would have as the commander of the defending force is water, food and ammunition (read arrows). Give me enough of these and I can hold the attackers off for a few weeks.
 

ThinkerX

Myth Weaver
Break out the shovels. Dig and hide pit traps inside the walls. Use rubble to make a second wall inside the first. Seal and trap all ground-level entrances to buildings, and throw up more rubble walls across streets to make kill zones with archers atop buildings.

For the walls proper: wait until the wind is right, heat sand in large trays until it is red-hot, load it into catapults or equivalent, then fire it in the direction of the enemy. Lots of fires and burns.
 
Top