- Thread starter
- #21
I don't think it has to be rigid, but a useful post on how best to critique a work should be posted and read by all. Even if you don't use it here, it would benefit you outside of these forums. Simple rules like:
For authors it would be something like:
I'm sure there is more, but the above seems to be the right direction.
- When commenting on a particular sentence use the Quote function located at the top of the Reply window.
- Be constructive instead of destructive
- Speak from your heart but don't assume everyone share the same heartbeat.
- It's better to comment thoroughly on one paragraph than halfhearted attempt on the entire posting.
- If the author begin to show teeth, note it and avoid any future postings.
- Address macro elements before micro elements.
For authors it would be something like:
- You are a big boy/girl now. If someone doesn't like what you wrote, accept it
- Don't engage in hostile interactions with your critics.
- It's fine to ask questions, but have an open mind on the response.
- If you need a bigger response on a particular point, use other forums and post that question.
- Don't tell critics "I'm not worried about grammar at this time." It's a cop out. Take all feedback, no matter what form it comes in.
- Post specific questions, it gives your critics an idea of what you're looking for.
- If you've posted specific questions and critics are responding to other points, don't get mad. Understand that those points may have been on such a large scale as to totally distract the reader.
- Grow thick skin and suck it up. You cannot exist in a bubble where you were constantly fortified with praise by those of your blood.
I'm sure there is more, but the above seems to be the right direction.